#116 of 132 Pensacola Beach Restaurants

Sky’s Pizza Pie

Sky's Pizza Pie – Satisfy Your Cravings for Cheesy Deliciousness in Pensacola, FL
Local Expert's Rating:
4.5 / 5
The Bottom Line:

Whenever you’re craving New York-style pizza made using ultra-fresh ingredients, you just need to skip on over to Sky’s Pizza Pie. At this Pensacola eatery, they make their dough fresh daily, and then add the perfect combo of toppings every time. Their Fried Ravioli, Bacon Cheddar Knots, and other delightful appetizers are equally good, keeping this pizza joint on the radar always.

- The FloridaPanhandle.com Local Expert Team

For a taste of amazing New York-style pizza without leaving the heart of Pensacola, just jet on into Sky’s Pizza Pie. The crew mixes up all their dough on the daily, and then tosses it by hand to create 16-, 18-, and monstrous 24-inch rounds. After that, each pizza gets a perfect amount of ultra-fresh toppings, including banana peppers, Italian sausage, and pineapple, before the mozzarella goes on top to bring it all together. Then, a trip through the oven gets each pizza bubbly, hot, and ready to devour with gusto.

Although their pizza easily steals the spotlight, all their offerings are just as delicious – and always made with care. They have tons of decadent appetizers ready to go, for example, including Tabasco Pickle Chips, Fried Ravioli, and their famous Pizza Dog. Plus, incredible garlic knots covered in savory flavors, like pesto feta and bacon cheddar. If that’s not enough to satisfy your cravings for pure deliciousness, you can even add classic or boneless wings to the mix. 

Surprisingly enough, their offerings don’t end there either. They have fresh salad available each and every day, of course. Then, they go all out with the calzones, stromboli, sub sandwiches, and chicken tender baskets. If you want to mix and match to create a meal all your own, you can even go with a single slice of cheese pizza plus whatever else looks good that day.

No matter how you want to build your meal, you always have the option to dine in and get takeout. Want to have your order delivered? They can usually do that as long as you hit their $30 order minimum. You’ll have to call to make sure, however, as their delivery days and hours change often.

Definitely sample their:

Pizza Dog
The Pizza Dog is a definite force to be reckoned with, leaving you craving another before you’re done with the first. They create this masterpiece by wrapping a large hot dog in a layer of pizza dough sprinkled with mozzarella. Then, they pop it into the oven until golden brown and serve it up with a side of marinara for dipping.

C.O.B. Pizza
When you’re in the mood for truly authentic upstate NY pizza, get the C.O.B., for sure. Available in 16-, 18-, and 24-inch sizes, this pie starts with hand-tossed dough every time. Then, they do a quick switcheroo with the toppings, putting the mozzarella on the bottom and red sauce on top.

Sky Popper Pizza
For a sweet and spicy flavor combo, treat yourself to the Sky Popper Pizza. To create this pie, they take your 16-, 18-, or 24-inch dough and cover it in cream cheese. After that, they top the cheese with pepperoni, sprinkle on jalapenos, and then pop it in the oven. Once it comes out, they drizzle spicy honey all over the top and serve it piping hot.

Chicken Parm Sub
If you’re in the mood for a wonderfully decadent chicken sandwich, order up the Chicken Parm Sub. This entrée begins with a breaded chicken patty cooked to perfection. After that’s done, they put it on a robust roll, add provolone and marinara, and then pop it into the oven until hot and bubbly.

If you want to take your dining experience to the next level, definitely save room for dessert. Their fresh-made dough only gets better when fried, topped with powdered sugar, and served with caramel and chocolate dipping sauce. Plus, they have decadent Blondies, Brownies, Cannolis, and so much more. Feeling too stuffed for even one more bite? Ask for your desserts of choice to go and enjoy them later in the evening.

Insider Tips:
-If you need to skip the wheat, just ask them to make your pie using their 13-inch gluten-free crust.
-Elevate your next party by having this pizza joint handle your catering. They’ll create 24-inch pizzas topped with all your favorite selections, and then bring the large salads and drinks to match.