#108 of 159 Panama City Beach Restaurants

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop

See all photos (8 Photos)
Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop - A Community Favorite for Excellent Desserts
Local Expert's Rating:
4.5 / 5
The Bottom Line:

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is a great place to go when you're craving a quality slice of pie. Plus, you can get a free 4" version just for signing up with their pie perks program. Known as the pie shop that gives a portion of its sales to the community, this is a good way to support Panama City Beach even if you're just passing through. 

- The FloridaPanhandle.com Local Expert Team

Americana comfort food lives in the latticework of traditional apple and the graham-cracker crusts of pecan pies. These treats are such a versatile and beloved dessert that nearly everyone is up for a slice at the end of a meal (or even for breakfast if no one is looking). 

Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop serves up pies in several sizes. Feed up to eight people with a 9″ pie or enjoy just two bites with the 2″ version. The 4″ pie is technically intended for one person, but there’s enough there for two people who just want to sample. The 4″ option is a particularly smart way to enjoy several varieties of Buttermilk Sky. 

A Pie Shop Rooted in Community 
This local chain has made it their mission to celebrate the differences in its communities rather than forcing a single standard on every shop. This place has a motto to pie it forward, meaning a portion of their sales goes right back into the community.

This little twist on traditional profits has inspired long-standing community members to try their hands at a franchise, bringing joy to their beloved neighbors and gaining an even stronger foothold as a pillar of their streets.

Want to buy a few seasonal flavors of pie and freeze to enjoy all year long? Unsure of whether your Chewy Chocolate Chip pie needs to go in the fridge? Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is happy to give you storage tips for every one of their specialties. And if you happen to be traveling, as so many of the Panama City Beach visitors are, they’re happy to help you find ways to transport your goodies too. 

If you’d take pie over cake any day, maybe you want your wedding to reflect this. This pie shop is ready to cater nearly any event, including retirement, anniversaries, birthday, and even corporate meetings. Bringing people together over a slice of pie, whether it’s a baby shower or a sporting event, is an excellent way to elevate your occasion. 

Here are a few of our favorite pies from their sweet menu:

I-40 
Named for the infamous freeway, this pie is a best-seller for blending the sweetness of chocolate chips along with real pecans and a pecan pie filling. The shortbread crust and sprinkle of coconut complete the perfect bite. 

Peanut Butter Cream
Whipped peanut butter and cream cheese plus an Oreo crust might be indulgent, but it’s also a combination that really satisfies with every bite. As rich as this may sound, the flavors are not overwhelming, meaning you won’t find yourself pushing the dessert away after just a bite or two. 

Coconut Cream 
With its tropical connotations, Panama City Beach calls for creamy, cool coconut cream. This pie is definitely incredible during the winter, but we would especially push it during the summer months. 

If you’re in Panama City Beach and looking for a way to satisfy your sweet tooth, Buttermilk Sky Pie Shop is a destination that shouldn’t be missed. Whether after a meal or just as a snack, you can taste the quality in every bite. 

Insider Tips:
– Join the  PIE PERKS Club for a free 4″ pie before you go. 
– Skip the line when you order online from their convenient website. 
– There are no savory pies served at this location, so come only when you want dessert.